I recently suffered a savage beating at the hands of some sort of alien pathogen that left me bedridden the whole weekend. Among the things that situation grants is more television time than any human deserves, regardless of his sins. I wasted a lot of time clearing out old recordings and reconfiguring “favorite channels” lists. While flipping through the channels, I came across something called Doomsday Preppers. I wondered if this was a reality show based on crackpot survivalists whose ideological expiration date was from the Reagan Administration. The individuals that were depicted on the show seemed fairly ordinary and somewhat rational. But there was something a little off-kilter. Then it hit me. What those people are doing (namely, preparing for a doomsday scenario) is precisely what right wing loons are trying to do within the confines of something more closely resembling reality.

Because I am still recovering from the mutant strain of space death, I will abbreviate doomsday preppers as DPs and Right Wing Loons as RWLs (humor me, I’m ill). Both the DP and the RWL suffer from a similar set of delusions. First, they assume imminent destruction of the world as we know it. For Glenn Beck followers, this is in the form of convoluted conspiracy theories readily dismissed by any but the most delusional cranks. For DPs, the requirement is less stringent in that it assumes no particular scenario other than a rapid collapse of civilization. This is the one place you will ever hear me opine that the RWLs are actually more reality-based than another group. By this, I mean that what they perceive has happened in history (see the European Dark Ages, the Warring States period in China, post-WWI Europe, pre-Tokugawa Shogunate Japan). But what the DPs are planning for is nearly unprecedented. That is to say, that the cases of complete societal collapse happened on relatively small scales (such as the Chaco Canyon and Mogollon cultures right here in New Mexico). In the case of vast civilizations, the aforementioned warlord-rule things came to pass.

What both sets of deluded nuts forget is this:

  1. In the case of RWLs, collapse of the societal structure in which you are stockpiling your savings as protection against hordes of swarthy unionist atheist liberal commie Muslim homos will render said stockpile, well, worthless.
  2. In the case of DPs, complete collapse of civilization will render you and every individual member of your family one otherwise minor ailment away from death. Did you know a tooth abscess can kill you?

But I can go ever further with regard to the DPs:

  1. Most of the intrinsically livable parts of the country are highly populated. When death by starvation is the alternative, I think a lot of “have nots” would raise a violent hand to the “haves.”
  2. If you choose a recently-populated area, you should be aware that many places are only agriculturally viable with large scale fertilization and seeds that do not allow for procreation. Once the area returns to its natural (or, possibly, depleted) state, it may be completely barren to humans.
  3. Each individual running any such DB habitation supposes that he will somehow remain in charge, not subject to challenge by his subjects. I wonder how that would work out…

I could go on and on, but the key point should be clear (again, assuming that NyQuil has not left me a babbling half-wit). Someone who is preparing for a different society in the context of the current society will find himself ill prepared. Worse yet, he will find himself surrounded by people just like him.